« 'Testament of Youth' director James Kent returns to matters of love and war in his second feature, with well-cast, well-dressed but less emotionally rewarding results. »
« For all that it has going on, including strong performances from its leads, the whole thing feels completely inert, and with an intensely deliberate pace is primarily just dull. »
« Le travail sur la lumière est très beau et instaure une ambiance surannée convaincante. Mais ces beaux passages ne font pas courber notre opinion, très défavorable dans son ensemble. »