L'homme Gémeau

« The movie is so disinterested in the philosophical issues it raises as to feel reluctant to commit to being this particular breed of science fiction (...). »

« Le plus désolant demeure le fait qu'Ang Lee (Ice Storm, L'histoire de Pi...) se soit tellement préoccupé de l'aspect technique de L'homme gémeau qu'il en ait oublié d'insuffler une âme à son film. »

« À l'arrivée, Gemini Man emprunte davantage les allures d'une enlevante randonnée en montagnes russes, à vivre préférablement en 3D. »

« Se gardant de donner vie et consistance à ce double rôle au potentiel psychologique et physique infini, Will Smith se contente d'une performance fonctionnelle, terne et sans relief. »

« 'Gemini Man" never pretends to be anything but a time-wasting contraption hoping to entertain its viewer. »

« Ang Lee blends an erratic script, listless performances and high frame-rate cinematography, and the results are terrible. »

« The bizarre combination of flesh-and-blood star Will Smith, his much younger digital clone, director Ang Lee and Jerry Bruckheimer makes for a high-concept misfire. »

« Smith fights a rubber-faced young clone of himself in this nonsensical assassin thriller. »

« (...) the film is full of superb 3D detailing, from grand widescreen cityscapes to slo-mo explosions that appear to scatter broken glass into the audience. »

« Take the spectacle away from GEMINI MAN and you're left with an action movie that's barely up to snuff and a rare misfire for its director. »

« It's a story that would have worked so much better when it started development in 1997, but now includes current-era visual effects that best serve the spectacle Gemini Man sets out to achieve. »